WHITTY Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 every nat winner is the best to whoever owns them
JADE Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 every one is good but this year would have to go for John Duthie at Reims
novo10 Posted November 7, 2010 Author Report Posted November 7, 2010 ur right every ones agood one but for me its fallahill superstar
billt Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 I Think the Busschaert cock, Ch. Adam would take some beating, 1st.Nat. Nantes 1st.Nat. Rennes 5th.Nat.Rennes 5th.Nat.Tours
VMS Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 For me it would have to be one that was won in the West Section.
Guest bakes Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 champion adam now owned by masserellas 1st national nantes 1st national rennes 5th national rennes 5th national tours got to be a good bird to beat this birds achievements. atb
JohnJ Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 whats been best national winner eddie newcombe with livecircut
sammy Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 Think there was a pigeon called Blue Blitz that was 1st open snfc rennes one year then beat in to 2nd spot by decimals the following year same race point not to sure but the name prigle selkirk springs to mind ,any one else remember
Guest strapper Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 i dont think there can be a comparison between national winners.different races /different distances /different weather conditions/different birdage...all can be brought into consideration.
JohnJ Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 Think there was a pigeon called Blue Blitz that was 1st open snfc rennes one year then beat in to 2nd spot by decimals the following year same race point not to sure but the name prigle selkirk springs to mind ,any one else remember ur right it was 1st and 2 nd open for jack wylie
sammy Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 ur right it was 1st and 2 nd open for jack wylie memory not as good john cheers
billt Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 i dont think there can be a comparison between national winners.different races /different distances /different weather conditions/different birdage...all can be brought into consideration.I agree there Paul, Thats why I think Adam was outstanding
Guest j.bamling Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 Ron williamsons Champion Millenium Superstar would take some beating for the amount of birds it beat time and time again
Guest jim lad Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 j poole newmains first rennes 1975 mealie hen braedale queen very hard race
dal2 Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 When I was a boy Jack Wylie was one of the nicest guys in the sport and gave me loads of encouragement. His doo was a cracker and its blood still runs thro my loft today! Probs a big bit bias but my uncle Jims doo Hoddom Dynamo has some outstanding results and is ready for next year! It is a life time ambition to be a nat winner and anybody that has the prize demands the upmost respect be it inland or channel. Will try again next year to win a race in the greatest club in the world!!!Cheers Steven
Guest bakes Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 Ron williamsons Champion Millenium Superstar would take some beating for the amount of birds it beat time and time again 1st Open 22,585 birds (Nenagh) in Ireland1st Open 22,889 birds (Mallow) in Ireland1st Open 23,767 birds (Tramore) in Ireland2nd Open 24,105 birds (Wexford) in Ireland (beaten by two loft mates) 16th Open 20,699 birds (Arklow) in Ireland Other open positions were also won by champion Ron-Ville-Millennium Superstar. Winning four R.P.R.A. awards in one season racing as follows: 1st R.P.R.A. Irish region 0 – 250 miles sprint champion; 1st R.P.R.A. Irish region Any Distance Champion; 1st R.P.R.A. National 0 – 250 miles champion (United Kingdom); 1stR.P.R.A. National Any distance champion (United Kingdom). Ron- Ville-Millennium Superstar also won the Selby Thomas Trophy for the 0 – 250 national sprint champion of the United Kingdom and the Tony Comwall trophy for the Any distance National champion of the United Kingdom. The 3 x 1st Opens won by Ron- Ville-Millennium Superstar were won three weeks in a row from three different race points. No other pigeon in the history of the N.I.P.A. has ever won the open three times, never mind three in a row. http://www.pigeonnetwork.com/articles/Ron_Williamson.html
Guest j.bamling Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 1st Open 22,585 birds (Nenagh) in Ireland1st Open 22,889 birds (Mallow) in Ireland1st Open 23,767 birds (Tramore) in Ireland2nd Open 24,105 birds (Wexford) in Ireland (beaten by two loft mates) 16th Open 20,699 birds (Arklow) in Ireland Other open positions were also won by champion Ron-Ville-Millennium Superstar. Winning four R.P.R.A. awards in one season racing as follows: 1st R.P.R.A. Irish region 0 – 250 miles sprint champion; 1st R.P.R.A. Irish region Any Distance Champion; 1st R.P.R.A. National 0 – 250 miles champion (United Kingdom); 1stR.P.R.A. National Any distance champion (United Kingdom). Ron- Ville-Millennium Superstar also won the Selby Thomas Trophy for the 0 – 250 national sprint champion of the United Kingdom and the Tony Comwall trophy for the Any distance National champion of the United Kingdom. The 3 x 1st Opens won by Ron- Ville-Millennium Superstar were won three weeks in a row from three different race points. No other pigeon in the history of the N.I.P.A. has ever won the open three times, never mind three in a row. http://www.pigeonnetwork.com/articles/Ron_Williamson.html Like i said not many pigeons on the Planet been better racers than that
Rooster J. Cogburn Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 John Proctor's "McFly" and "Lucky Jim" are two that have impressed me very much in recent times.Only pigeons into Scotland on the night from 600+ miles.The fact the birdages are so small makes it all the more impressive when you think of the work those pigeons had to do on their own. Into my Fed "Flora Macdonald" the Anderson Bros 1939 Rennes winner is a bit of a legend.Into whats known today as Section Dyou'd have to hand it to Jock Watson's 1975 Avranches winner on the night.Or Stuart Peaston's 1st and 2nd Avranches on the night Got to take your hat off to any National winner really whilst still taking into account it may not be the races best performance
alec guinness Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 For me it would have to be one that was won in the West Section. same for me,
Rooster J. Cogburn Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 same for me, Aye its not easy to win a national into the West Section.Theres been/is a fair few fanciers through there that could easily fall into "best ever" category despite not actually winning a national
alec guinness Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 Aye its not easy to win a national into the West Section.Theres been/is a fair few fanciers through there that could easily fall into "best ever" category despite not actually winning a national just an opinion lewis,all national winners are fantastic and make the fanciers the stuff of folklore,hope you got your trophy mate,the night was a great success and seeing some of the north west federation trophies going back decades lined with famous names past and present it was a priviledge to present them. :) :)
jim cowie Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 there has been a lot of outstanding birds clocked in the north section that never won a national,including the six gold award winners.so an all time great has to be "marlene,s girl".1st open from andrezel 626mls on the day for Davie Pirie Aberdeen.
blue63 Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 my father won rennes GOLD CUP with a yearling
alec guinness Posted November 7, 2010 Report Posted November 7, 2010 my father won rennes GOLD CUP with a yearling was it 1973 by any chance???????????
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now