SNFC /RPRA

[naedoos]

SAYS WHO ITS LIKE THE S.N.F.C WANT THE R.P.R.A GUYS TO JOIN THEN

 

 

All you've got to do is read the posts on here mate

[stoolpigeon]

WELL ITS DOWN TO EACH WHO THEY FLY WITH I DNT THINK THERE WLL EVER BE ANY GOING BACK MATE

[stoolpigeon]

YOULL NEVER GET 1 FED EVER AGAIN  

[ALF]

It's not about this 1 is better than that 1 it's about sorting out what went wrong in the 1st place and let's get back to having some peace and harmony and all racing our doos together again!

[naedoos]

WELL ITS DOWN TO EACH WHO THEY FLY WITH I DNT THINK THERE WLL EVER BE ANY GOING BACK MATE

 

Exactly, no one has to do anything they don't want to, but you've obviously made your mind up already

[stoolpigeon]

I WOULD NEVER GO BACK THE WAY NOT FED OR NAT  

[naedoos]

I WOULD NEVER GO BACK THE WAY NOT FED OR NAT  

 

That's okay you're entitled to your opinion, just as well there are other minded fanciers

[Guest bigda]

I WOULD NEVER GO BACK THE WAY NOT FED OR NAT  

 

you might not go back the way, but should the snfc  change the rule, and allow  members to join, i would put money on it what one would win, in the long term so the snrpc  at least know that and  have to  keep stoom, in-case there is a run on membership 400 members are alright  but whats the age group  like dodgy,  so never say never and hope you do get the choice as only time will tell

[maverick]

maybe a lot in what you say chairman, but i think we should also ask what the early founders would say, when fanciers of long standing the likes of dennis dall, john ellis, peter virtue, jim benvie, john proctor, pete patrick, kerr stainthorpe, stuart mullan, davie elliot, ken buchanan, wilson and jack, and many others too numerous to list, decided to walk away from the snfc. for anyone who is thinking in any way they must ask why?

 

JOHNO    Could you tell us how many of the fanciers you named fly in both the nationals

[hotrod]

Apart from davie elliot im positive none of the others do .Definately not me anyway

[maverick]

nothing bad meant was just asking as i know a lot of fanciers are now in both

[weecunny]

lets join the rpra and the snfc and keep the rpra commitee 2 run it

[maverick]

lets join the rpra and the snfc and keep the rpra commitee 2 run it

 

AND YOU ARE A SCOTSMAN

[weecunny]

lol but a ken whats giud for mi lol

 

[maverick]

You have a voice go to the meeting and air your views there thats the only place things can get sorted not on here.If all the folk on here that had there say spouting off on this and that went to the meeting WE could get all sorted out.

[Guest]

lets join the rpra and the snfc and keep the rpra commitee 2 run it

 

lol another joker(evil)

[weecunny]

;D

[JADE]

lets join the rpra and the snfc and keep the rpra commitee 2 run it

 

the rpra cannae run their own affairs never mind the SCOTTISH national

[Guest]

what rules do you think they would need to change if this proposal was passed ie rpra members right to appeal, measurments , etc would it be up to the commitee to change them

[ALF]

what rules do you think they would need to change if this proposal was passed ie rpra members right to appeal, measurments , etc would it be up to the commitee to change them

 

i THINK THAT WOULD HAVE TO BE VOTED ON FRANK BUT I THINK A COMMITEE WOULD HAVE TO DECIDE IT THOUGH

[JADE]

i think for it to work the snfc would have to be independent of any union. i cant see how a club of the stature of the snfc could operate under the rules of two separate unions without there being a conflict in the rules somewhere along the line. but if the will is there i`m sure it can be done.  

[Guest IB]

Wondered how SNRPC handled disputes just now?

 

Seems off if Union membership decides which Union the dispute is appealed to? I think there are differences in both Union's rules?

 

Appeal Court is only fair if it is completely autonomous. Committee sounds like its part of the same Organisation. Can't sit in final judgement over something you've ruled on previously.

 

[Guest]

yes i think ib and jade are correct it might work if it anserewed to its self maybe with the right to appeal to a commitee made up from say 5/7 made up from senior members of other unions not involved, or people of good standing from out side pigeons after all they can only rule on was any rule broken so do they need to be pigeon fanciers at all may be 1 just to give guidance the snrpc has a 5 man apeal comitee with the right to apeal to the rpra but has never been needed

[maverick]

IF you join any club in any walk of life you join and abide by there rules you dont get to change the rules before you join

[Guest]

dont disagree maverick but what about the apeal system if this goes through it would need to change and the snfc may have to affiliate to the various unions to allow they members that right