Snfc / Snrpc

[elanco]

In each section, just to stop an argument brewing , and one day , does the members of both hope we fly as one again ?, I doo !!!

[blue pied]

in my section E has to be snfc:Davie donaldson, Davie elliot,john houtson

SNRPC: donald mathison, john callan, Billy davidson

 

Section F : derek Hay and Ian ross?

[Guest stb-]

in my section E has to be snfc:Davie donaldson, Davie elliot,john houtson

SNRPC: donald mathison, john callan, Billy davidson

 

Section F : derek Hay and Ian ross?

dereks in sect e aswell ya muppet and with 5 first west regions will be up there with the others

[blue pied]

dereks in sect e aswell ya muppet and with 5 first west regions will be up there with the others

its late at night , im tired , geez a break haha

[JohnQuinn]

Yes i would LOVE both organisations getting back together, i think if that comes about, the result would be that there was a lot stronger club at the end of the day and better racing with a larger birdage, everyone's a winner. jmo.

[hotrod]

Top five in no order ,

 

Snfc

 

Mr @mrs Elliot , j@ I Alston, j.houston, w. Allison , d.hay

 

Snrpc

 

 

J.callan, Wilson @ jack , k.buchannan, w.davidson @ son, I. Ross.

 

This in the west region not section e and f

 

And of course yes to the main question

[geordie1234]

What about adding the northwest fed there's some members flying further west than alot in the west section

That's true

[Pelican]

Snfc j.king, j.Bosworth,.d.elliot, d.hay, g.hunter n son

[Pelican]

Snrpc p virtue, b.mckenzie, a.lees, g.Anderson, d.burns

[stevie bannon]

Snfc john duthie jocky king karen newcombe dave glen billy bilsland j alston

Snrpc g anderson scone andrew lees peter virtue

[Delboy]

This thread turned into a fed thread, back to topic. Snfc, GB.Hunter,J.Bosworth, Jock King, Scott Irving, John Mcneil. Snrpc. Bruce Mckenzie, P.Virtue, J.Anderson, D.Burns, J.Ellis

[hotrod]

I posted my thoughts of top west fanciers , the east. Would be.

 

Snfc

 

J.mcneill, g hunter, j bosworth , j.king, j.duthie

 

 

Snrpc

 

P.virtue, j.bell, d,burns, d white and jim Anderson both cardenden .

[hotrod]

The south.

 

Snfc

 

D .norden. , j m dalgliesh , jim seaton , r Rome , s Irvine jnr .

[hotrod]

The north

 

Snfc

 

J Donaldson , prob dominates this section , noticed a name the last few years. Getting in is g wetherly. Aberdeen .

[tiger]

snfc only north , j Donaldson

east , g hunter , j king , r combe , a simpson ,

west , d eillot, j aliston, j Houston, morris bos .

south , g grant, s irving, d norden .

[JohnQuinn]

This thread turned into a fed thread, back to topic. Snfc, GB.Hunter,J.Bosworth, Jock King, Scott Irving, John Mcneil. Snrpc. Bruce Mckenzie, P.Virtue, J.Anderson, D.Burns, J.Ellis

 

Aye it does seem to have gone off topic Derek, but having read the "on topic" posts i canny see John Hodgson's name anywhere. A man who's won 7 x 1st Open SNFC races and he disnae get a mention expletive remove!!!

Its like all other threads on this subject, and there have been plenty of them, its meaningless.

At least the Joint Convoying of Federations as a subject has some possibility of integrating the fancy in the west, a positive step forward for us, people's opinion on who's best here there or anywhere else is a load of ***** and is brought up year on year, sometimes more than once a year or season, it's totally meaningless hence my earlier "on topic" post does Not include who's best, only that i would love to see both organisations getting together again, because i have posted my opinion on "who's best" many times and as far as i know its made not an iota of difference to anyone.

Just as the names put forward on this thread will make no difference to anyone, not now or at any other time.

The man who started the topic is imo the man who should, if he chooses to, ask for all "off topic" posts to be transferred away from this thread to a more appropriate one, but he hasn't so he must be happy with the discussion that has developed on His Thread. Cheers, John.

[Delboy]

Aye it does seem to have gone off topic Derek, but having read the "on topic" posts i canny see John Hodgson's name anywhere. A man who's won 7 x 1st Open SNFC races and he disnae get a mention expletive remove!!!

Its like all other threads on this subject, and there have been plenty of them, its meaningless.

At least the Joint Convoying of Federations as a subject has some possibility of integrating the fancy in the west, a positive step forward for us, people's opinion on who's best here there or anywhere else is a load of ***** and is brought up year on year, sometimes more than once a year or season, it's totally meaningless hence my earlier "on topic" post does Not include who's best, only that i would love to see both organisations getting together again, because i have posted my opinion on "who's best" many times and as far as i know its made not an iota of difference to anyone.

Just as the names put forward on this thread will make no difference to anyone, not now or at any other time.

The man who started the topic is imo the man who should, if he chooses to, ask for all "off topic" posts to be transferred away from this thread to a more appropriate one, but he hasn't so he must be happy with the discussion that has developed on His Thread. Cheers, John.

 

John, Hodgy hasn't flown well for a few seasons m8.Dont think hes got a ticket in the last 2 years ?? so how can he be the top in the last five years.

[JohnQuinn]

Because every fancier gets a wee blip here and there, it disnae all of a sudden make them a bad fancier, so for my money John would be on ANY list that included the best fanciers in the SNFC and not just the South. jmo.

[tiger]

Because every fancier gets a wee blip here and there, it disnae all of a sudden make them a bad fancier, so for my money John would be on ANY list that included the best fanciers in the SNFC and not just the South. jmo.

 

 

am sure john moved house this year , top doo man

[hotrod]

Because every fancier gets a wee blip here and there, it disnae all of a sudden make them a bad fancier, so for my money John would be on ANY list that included the best fanciers in the SNFC and not just the South. jmo.

John the thread was about the last 5 years not of all time then yes John hodgson would be in the top 5 IMHO . But going on last 5 years timing in most if not all races ,overseas are the only ones I'm rating on .

[Delboy]

Because every fancier gets a wee blip here and there, it disnae all of a sudden make them a bad fancier, so for my money John would be on ANY list that included the best fanciers in the SNFC and not just the South. jmo.

 

I thought the question was in the last 5 years, well in the last 5 years he has been below his usual standard imo. Nobody can question how good hes been in the past in the south section.

 

Great minds think alike Stu lol

[JohnQuinn]

Still a meaningless exercise

[just ask me]

ill split the thread in a few mins it may read a little odd as the natural flow of the thread will be interrupted

[hotrod]

snfc only north , j Donaldson

east , g hunter , j king , r combe , a simpson ,

west , d eillot, j aliston, j Houston, morris bos .

south , g grant, s irving, d norden .

Your having a laugh John , Morris bros? Yes top flyers through here but I'm sure they would be saying the same as me , expletive remove out of the last 5 gold cup races they have timed in 1 race , they have a long way to go to catch up some others in the west likewise myself , I could name prob 20/30 in front of robert and David , and I'm not rubbishing them one bit , good guys and work hard for their results , some are top class no doubt about it but consistency is what you look for . Imho

[tiger]

Your having a laugh John , Morris bros? Yes top flyers through here but I'm sure they would be saying the same as me , expletive remove out of the last 5 gold cup races they have timed in 1 race , they have a long way to go to catch up some others in the west likewise myself , I could name prob 20/30 in front of robert and David , and I'm not rubbishing them one bit , good guys and work hard for their results , some are top class no doubt about it but consistency is what you look for . Imho

 

that's my pick mate and if I was 2 pick a other would have been hoods