Who Is The Best All Round Dooman Since E Newcombe

[Guest Gareth Rankin]

What about that guy S Gibson.

 

Wrong time of the year Jim, re-post on the 1st of April

[lanarkshire lad]

Wrong time of the year Jim, re-post on the 1st of April

Sorry Gareth

[JohnQuinn]

Sartilly 2 in 1987 which was a tough/disaster of a race

 

 

Cheers Gareth, i new it was Sartilly but couldn't remember the year. He also has a gold award winner to his name, which if i'm correct was won in the Rennes DISASTER of 1993ish, this i think was a Dark Ck bird.

[lanarkshire lad]

Cheers Gareth, i new it was Sartilly but couldn't remember the year. He also has a gold award winner to his name, which if i'm correct was won in the Rennes DISASTER of 1993ish, this i think was a Dark Ck bird.

I think the dk ch was the nat winner and was it not a mealy that won a Gold Award.

[JohnQuinn]

I think it was a Mealy Hen he won the national with Jim

[Guest Gareth Rankin]

I think the dk ch was the nat winner and was it not a mealy that won a Gold Award.

 

Correct,won gold award in 1988, and something tells me he also won another gold award in 1995

[JohnJ]

John Hodgson Annan.Nobody past or present has a track record like his from the nats.

yes 1st class

[JohnQuinn]

I have my books at the loft so canny argue one way or the other as i am only going by what my memory tells me, which is no as good as it was!!! Either way he still gets ma vote as the TOP dooman in the country since E.N.

 

 

[wullie semple]

yes 1st class

john i think it was a dark cock he won with the mealy cock won a gold award but i think they have won two gold awards yes great allrounders

[clockman]

Correct,won gold award in 1988, and something tells me he also won another gold award in 1995

97,

[lanarkshire lad]

john i think it was a dark cock he won with the mealy cock won a gold award but i think they have won two gold awards yes great allrounders

Was the mealy not called Janefield Geordie and had some Bobby Carruthers blood in it.

[yeboah]

We have many top doomen in our fed

 

Who could argue against john hodgson ,seven national wins and all from the channel,

 

And john only has time to work the birds when time permits just think what he could

 

achieve if full time dooman ,

 

One of the great all rounders has to be my good friend jimmy dal from the fechan

 

jimmy wins in the club and fed from the first to last race with only a handful

 

of birds and i mean handful

 

His national record is fantastic from all racepoints ,he once bred and raced tranquillity boy

 

that was one of the best birds in scotland at the time,He now races hoddam dynamo which has

 

a first and third open national to its credit from the channel plus other top national positions

 

also numerous club and fed tickets ,No of anyone with a bird of this standing cos i don't .

 

Top Top DOOMAN .

[Delboy]

Jimmy Dalgliesh is a very good dooman as well as being a gentleman. The sport lacks the likes of Jimmy.

[yeboah]

Jimmy Dalgliesh is a very good dooman as well as being a gentleman. The sport lacks the likes of Jimmy.

 

Well said Delboy .

[virgin of the sky]

Newcombe was never all rounder if you mean the best Snfc flyer since he departed you have 4 greats Hodgson,Andy Miller,Kinnears and Donaldson.

[lanarkshire lad]

Newcombe was never all rounder if you mean the best Snfc flyer since he departed you have 4 greats Hodgson,Andy Miller,Kinnears and Donaldson.

By the way there are some greats in the west section that dont get the recognition they deserve due to loft location.

[yeboah]

By the way there are some greats in the west section that dont get the recognition they deserve due to loft location.

 

There has always been great fanciers in the west section and still are some of them my

 

very good friends omo think if you put yours doos back on line they would be GREAT again .

[virgin of the sky]

By the way there are some greats in the west section that dont get the recognition they deserve due to loft location.

tell us who you think then present not past and who do you think will be in the future.do you sprint or distance.

[lanarkshire lad]

tell us who you think then present not past and who do you think will be in the future.do you sprint or distance.

Jim Hannah for a start i think hes won the west section from the channel about seven times .If he was over in the east section he would be as good or even better than the guys ou mentioned.IMO

[virgin of the sky]

Jim Hannah for a start i think hes won the west section from the channel about seven times .If he was over in the east section he would be as good or even better than the guys ou mentioned.IMO

many tickets have you won in the past 5 years or do you sprint

[JohnQuinn]

many tickets have you won in the past 5 years or do you sprint

 

 

I cannot answer your question but, Louella came and BOUGHT doos from Jim, (lanarkshire lad) how many on here can say that??

[lanarkshire lad]

many tickets have you won in the past 5 years or do you sprint

I do a wee bit of everything mate what about yourself?

[alec guinness]

Newcombe was never all rounder if you mean the best Snfc flyer since he departed you have 4 greats Hodgson,Andy Miller,Kinnears and Donaldson.

 

some top performers in your list some though with a good bit to go,same old question that always comes up then ends in a rabble,to answer the question imo,

BEST ALLROUNDER JOHN MCNEIL BROXBURN.

[virgin of the sky]

I do a wee bit of everything mate what about yourself?

just startin up were the doos jquinn talking about sprinters /distance and are the still winning

 

I do a wee bit of everything mate what about yourself?

just startin up were the doos jquinn talking about sprinters /distance and are the still winning

[budgie]

In the West Sect we have some great fanciers namely Jim Hannah,Rankins,Cullen and the McAlonies if its all rounders.