WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS ON THIS

[Guest IB]

Think there's more to this than we are being told. Nobody would apply for an award for a pigeon they'd raced that wasn't registered in their name. Person would also be suspended when caught, this one wasn't suspended, so appears there are special circumstances attached to this case that haven't been disclosed to us.

[Guest strapper]

i have been in a situation similar to this.

i had a pigeon return over a year a go.

it was a 2004 pigeon..it had someone elses phone ring on it.

so i rang the number to see who had been racing my bird...to cut the story short..the guy had reported the bird but told the whu a digit the wrong way round..mine was 54 end number he told them 45..which happened to be a club member of mine who had packed in.

well the transfer went through and he raced my bird believing that he had transfered it over correctly.

the bird scored well in the fed for him .

well i had the bird back and raced it it went straight back to him 1st race..so i transfered the bird correctly to him...that bird would be let out and return to me...it went back and for untill one day he let it out and it didnt return to either of us...mr hawk i think made a meal of it.

 

a simple mistake through the transferring..me and the guy now are m8s and bump into each other from time to time.

 

so we shouldnt judge the guy in the threads matter till the truth comes out.

[Guest lee duffy]

IF A FANCIER WAS CAUGHT WITH SOME ONES BIRD IN THERE LOFT AND WON CLUBS FEDS,NATIONALS WITH THAT BIRD, SHOULD HE BE BANNED FROM RACING PIGEONS.

 

 

 

 

how could he get away with it in the first place your suppose to see the transfair sheet if its not a club bird. so its also the clubs fault

[Guest Davy Fleming]

Well said strapper

[Guest BIRD_MAN_JOHN]

 

how could he get away with it in the first place your suppose to see the transfair sheet if its not a club bird. so its also the clubs fault

 

SENT PM

[kingbilly2]

 

SENT PM

 

is this not the same as straging a doo in and breading of it because you like the look of it to me its just the same and hapens more  this was coverd on another thread and dident get the same respons totaly out of order :D

[Guest stb-]

 

is this not the same as straging a doo in and breading of it because you like the look of it to me its just the same and hapens more  this was coverd on another thread and dident get the same respons totaly out of order :D

 

Tam did ye not ask Bert his thots on it when he was doing the BHW REPORT FER YE ;D 8) ;D ;D

[Tony C]

 

It may go back to region but if they did turn the clubs decision over it could be apealed to council and i'm sure they would want to know why the region ignored the problem in the first place. As it stands nobody can take it to council to be resolved.

 

The person/s who took it to region can appeal against the decision then it would go before council.

[pjc]

 

The person/s who took it to region can appeal against the decision then it would go before council.

 

It hasn't been taken to region as far as it reads. As far as I see it the member placed claim for a region award, the bird was found not to be his so region placed it on there own agenda, efectively region took it to region so nobody to appeal!

[Tony C]

 

It hasn't been taken to region as far as it reads. As far as I see it the member placed claim for a region award, the bird was found not to be his so region placed it on there own agenda, efectively region took it to region so nobody to appeal!

 

Have you the page number and date of Homing World please Phil.

[Guest mr mrs arnold sons]

i was at the west midlands meeting when that matter was discussed

and is was dealt with

[pjc]

 

Have you the page number and date of Homing World please Phil.

 

This weeks BHW, west midland region meeting report i understand.

[Fair Play]

What happens if you buy a bird in a sale and do not receive a transfer and contact the previous owner (twice) but still no transfer after promising to send it (still have the emails) should I smell a rat or contact the RPRA to see who is the rightful owner

[Tony C]

 

This weeks BHW, west midland region meeting report i understand.

 

It reads as if this decision was taken at a previous meeting. There's mention of a letter of complaint under matters arising re rule 118 possibly under the Grievances and Disciplinary Procedure

 

Grievances and Disciplinary Matters

168. If any member of an organisation has a

grievance, dispute or complaint concerning

the Organisation he may within 28 days of the

grievance, dispute or complaint arising give

notice in writing of his grievance, dispute or

complaint to the secretary of the

Organisation, requiring the secretary to

convene a general meeting or if the rules of

the Organisation so prescribe, a meeting of

the Committee of the Organisation to consider

the grievance, dispute or complaint. Any such

meeting shall be convened by the secretary by

not less than 7 days notice in writing to all

members entitled to attend such meeting and

to all parties to grievance, dispute or

complaint.

[pjc]

 

It reads as if this decision was taken at a previous meeting. There's mention of a letter of complaint under matters arising re rule 118 possibly under the Grievances and Disciplinary Procedure

 

Grievances and Disciplinary Matters

168. If any member of an organisation has a

grievance, dispute or complaint concerning

the Organisation he may within 28 days of the

grievance, dispute or complaint arising give

notice in writing of his grievance, dispute or

complaint to the secretary of the

Organisation, requiring the secretary to

convene a general meeting or if the rules of

the Organisation so prescribe, a meeting of

the Committee of the Organisation to consider

the grievance, dispute or complaint. Any such

meeting shall be convened by the secretary by

not less than 7 days notice in writing to all

members entitled to attend such meeting and

to all parties to grievance, dispute or

complaint.

 

I think tony said original letter was in BHW about 2 weeks ago.

 

The organisation refers to a club or fed and not region and as far as i can see the matter hasn't been taken to region by a club.