Jack
You put forward some good points.
But I still feel, there is no simple, or rules in this game.
Take for instance the Sun City race, millions not hundreds of variables are at play.
This all under one type of management, Luck, buckets of it, and top pigeons are needed.
Much like at a fanciers backyard loft.
Yet, the top Ten is not won by Selectors or Click pairs, as even here, one year a pair can breed a winner in each nest, and the next year not breed one.
Their eyes have not changed, but it is the nature of this game, that I feel keeps us all trying.
I think that this is were the true secrets lie, hidden from everyone by nature.
If any found the solution to Breeding winners, first they would never need to send more than 1 pigeon to the race, as they have the winner selected.
Second they would keep 2 stock pairs at most, as they would not need more.
This I have yet to see.
Much like the throat theory, followed by 2 of Englands best fanciers. They let everyone know of it last year.
No bet it wont change anything, they will still be top, and every fancier that trys out the theory, wont change anything.
As no matter what this game is all about a top quality base of pigeons.
From there I think anything and everything can be applied, as top pigeons are very forgiving on fanciers mistakes or applied theories.
Regards saffer