Quite correct, the PMV vaccine was also unavailable during the same period. The use of the vaccines is to enable the development of immune memory. If your birds met PMV or Paratyphoid at some time during that year, then theoretically they will mount a quicker immune response and therefore suffer less. Neither vaccine is designed to prevent infection, only the development of clinical disease. There is usually in a reduction of spread of the infection as well. Correct about the specificity of the paratyphoid vaccine. Pigeons only suffer disease when infected with the pigeon strain of Salmonella typhimurium. Pigeons like chickens can be infected with the majority of the remaining 2,300 + strains without blinking an eye. It is us that suffers from the diarrhoea and associated problems. So the vaccines protect against the strain that causes the problem. Lastly, the live vaccines do not usually cause disease. pointless having them if they did. Thank you for highlighting all these points. David