I agree with a lot of your points of view regarding eye-sign, it is not the be all and end all, to found a loft upon. but many years ago i did pick out a top stock pair from over 40 birds at a clearance sale when i restarted in the sport, but i selected them in the dark for balance , feathering etc' before i even looked into their eyes. I was left with about eight birds, disposing of the others. I then went over them several times before i made my final choice, i picked a Dark pied cock with what could be described as having a green eye and a little blue pied hen with a true gold eye, this pair bred me over 20 1st prize winners out to Poitiers 421 miles, the hen was killed by a cat two years later, both bred winners with other mates, but none where ever lost from them as a pair, but half was lost with other partners. When i called it a day i gave the cock and a few of his sons and daughters to a club mate who went on to breed winner after winner with them out to Thurso, about 435 miles, year after year in good competition. I restarted again in 2006 with birds from two different top fanciers and have a team of 12 cocks for next season,some have good eye-sign, some not so good, but all their eyes tell me they have a good constitution with eyes shining like fires which is what i really look for in an eye. For some reason that im not sure of, im able to go to a fanciers loft and pick out his best couple of breeders and am often asked to do this... The pic of your bird reminds me of a Cheq hen that i had, that won 8x 1sts but never bred me a winner, i have a pic of her eye which i will put on here for you to have a look at. These days with ill health i just enjoy having my birds around me.