yes that was my thoughts the so called hen was 3 years old and im sure they have had pigeons enough years to be able to sex a 3 year old bird i would of fully understood and accepted the mistake even if had been a yearling. my sons are only 12 and 13 and cannot believe they havent even had a reply. they spent there first money on pigeons at a entire clearance sale not so long ago and spent quite a bit of money which they had saved for a long time, there was a couple of pigeons that had been left at the home of the seller and at the end of the sale the auctioneer made a gift of a cheq pied hen that had not been sold and told the seller that he would pay for the carriage, they went out and also bought a cock to go to this hen that they are still waiting for to this day, people wonder why new young fanciers dont want to come into the sport.