I think you missing Pigeonscouts point, and its the most valid on the topic.
We only have 1 measurement in this Game, Results.
So instead of nit-picking posts, he posted Questions, and as yet I see no valisd answer.
EG: Pigeonfancier X, he says give Garlic everyday. Now Pigeonfancier X swears by this.
We must look for validity in the point, ie. Pigeonfancier X is Club champion, he has been 7 times out of the lat 10 years, and ver out the top 10 in the Fed.
Weight and validity is very great on his point, as his results prove this.
Hence an Eye sign man, has a huge bit of power, he can select better than anyone else. So his concentration of Quality is far higher than average Joe.
Hence he should be a crack, champion flyer as result???
I have the same Question, as the power to select, is huge, hence the results should be just as great.
Regards
Saffer